- The Pen Pivot
- Posts
- Color Consistency: The Untapped Secret To Addictive Content
Color Consistency: The Untapped Secret To Addictive Content

Welcome to The Pen Pivot!
We share the tactics and psychology-backed secrets of great content creators so you can replicate their success.
In todayās email:
Tip Of The Day šØ - How to use color consistency in your content to increase familiarity and trust with your audience.
Tool Of The Day š ļø - A free tool to help you nail the perfect color scheme for your creator brand.
But firstā¦
An Update!
Introducing:
Pen Pivot Pro ā our premium newsletter edition specifically made for online writers looking to master the psychology behind engaging their audience.
While our Wednesday edition will remain free for everyone, Fridays will now be exclusive to our Pro subscribers.
Here's what Pen Pivot Pro offersā¦
Weekly deep dives written for:
Bloggers
Newsletter Writers
Video Scriptwriters
Copywriters
Anyone else that writes content online
Psychology-backed writing techniques to boost clicks, retention, engagement, shares, and revenue.
Plus, in-depth tactics for using AI tools like ChatGPT to make your content more effective.
If you donāt do much writing or youāre just happy to stick with our free edition, no worries! We love having you here.
But if you're keen to take your online writing to the next level, click below!

-COLOR CONSISTENCY-
The Bottom Line šØ
Using consistent colors in your content will:
Increase your audienceās preference for your content.
Increase your audienceās trust in your content.
Help your content stand out among a sea of inconsistent creators.
How Does Color Consistency Do This? š¤
Here are a couple of ways:
š” Familiarity:
Familiarity leads to preference and likeability.
Creators donāt take advantage of this enough.
In the 1960s, Zajonc showed that familiar items are rated more positively than unfamiliar ones.
Itās called the āMere Exposure Effectā.
Itās been demonstrated in lots of different fields since then.
Consistent colors will make your content more familiar and more likable as a result.
š” Isolation:
Creators have never had as much competition.
Anyone with access to a smartphone is creating content these days.
So how do you stand out?
Van Restorff found that an item that differs from the rest of the group is more likely to be remembered.
As youād expect, this is now called The Van Restorff Effect.
Think of a purple sheep among a sea of white sheep.
Itās more than likely youāll remember the purple one.
Being the creator with a ruthlessly consistent color scheme will help you stand out among a sea of inconsistent competitors.
Examples Of Creators Doing It Right š
Expert creators understand the importance of color consistency in content.
Here are a couple of them:
A phenomenal retro gaming content empire created by Brandon Saltalamacchia.
They take color consistency seriously.
Its green and purple scheme is scattered throughout its blog posts and YouTube videos.

A huge YouTube channel and blog dedicated to healthy eating.
The beautiful shades of green they use are closely aligned with the overall content messaging.

How You Can Apply This As A Creator šØ
OK, so how do you use these nuggets of knowledge to your advantage?
š BLOGGERS
Consistent Palette: Choose a color palette and stick to it for major blog elements. Headers, banners, and call-to-action buttons.
Highlight Key Information: Use consistent colors for headings, keywords, links, and quotations.
Images and Graphics: Ensure images, infographics, and other visual elements are designed in line with your chosen color palette.
Overall Branding: Include a consistent color-themed logo and favicon.
š¹ YOUTUBERS
Thumbnail Design: Use consistent colors for your video thumbnails. It makes videos recognizable among the many other thumbnails on the home screen/recommendations tab.
Channel Art: Make sure your YouTube channel banner and profile picture match your brand colors.
Text & Graphics in Videos: When adding text or graphics to your videos, keep the color consistent with your branding.
š¬ SOCIAL MEDIA CREATORS
Profile Aesthetics: Ensure profile pictures, banners, and backgrounds are consistent in color and theme.
Post Templates: Use consistent color templates for posts, especially for recurring content (e.g., "Tip Tuesday" or "Quote of the Day").
Stories & Highlights: Use consistently colored backgrounds, text, or even colored frames/borders for stories and story highlights.
š± SHORT FORM VIDEO CREATORS
Consistent Filters: Use filters that align with your brand colors and mood.
Overlays & Text: Add captions, text, or overlays in your brand colors to highlight key messages.
Intro/Outro Slides: Have a consistent colored slide at the beginning or end of your videos.

-TOOL OF THE DAY-
COOLORS
Letās assume weāve gotten you suitably hyped about color consistency.
If youāre looking to take your color schemes more seriously, check out Coolors.
Itās an awesome free tool that uses color theory to generate beautiful color palettes you can use in your content.
(Not Sponsored)
And thatās all for today!
Donāt forget to check out Pen Pivot Pro if youāre a digital writer and want to go deeper on this type of content š
Dilshan and Misya
The Pen Pivot