- The Pen Pivot
- Posts
- 🤔 Dumb it down
🤔 Dumb it down

🧠 IN TODAY’S EMAIL
🧪 Hook Science:
Get more clicks by dumbing it down.
💡 A Clickable Content Idea For You:
How successful people in your niche achieve their biggest goals.
Headline template included 👍️
🏅 Hook Of The Day:
This 1-page letter brought in 20,000 orders/day.
🧪 HOOK SCIENCE
Get More Clicks By Dumbing Down Your Headlines
Which headline would you click on:
“This Ultra-Light $35 Kitchen Mop Was Voted #1 By Cleaning Pros”
“This Economical And Featherweight Kitchen Mop Is Championed By Cleaning Maestros”
Probably the first one, right?

A harsh, but fair rule-of-thumb:
The audience is looking for any excuse to ignore your content.
A headline is essentially a job application.
You’re applying for their attention and making a case for why your content is worthy of their time.
Writing a long-winded or confusing headline will lead to the content getting ignored.
Cut the fluff and get to the point.
Avoid the following:
Complex language or jargon
Vagueness
Irrelevant details
Abstract or cryptic phrasing
Let the audience know exactly what’s in it for them with the minimum number of words.
🧠 Why It Works:
Cognitive Fluency: Simple headlines require less mental effort to process — the benefit of the content is clearer.
Accessibility: Headlines that can be understood by a wider audience will inevitably get more attention.
💡 Takeaway: Run your headlines through Hemingway Editor (for free) and aim for reading level that’s below 8th Grade.
💡 A CLICKABLE CONTENT IDEA FOR YOU
How Successful People In Your Niche Achieve Their Biggest Goals
🔨 Your Headline Template:
"How [Successful Group Of People In Your Niche] Achieve [Big Goal] (+ Why You Can’t Even [Achieve Small Goal])"
🔎 The Inspiration:
“How Successful People Achieve Multiple Goals (+ Why You Can't Even Manage One)”
🧠 Why The Headline Works:
Aspiration: It taps into a universal desire for success — this motivates the audience to learn from successful people in the niche.
Pain Point: Finishing with “why you can’t even [x]” touches on a pain point — it’s bold and grabs attention.
🔁 How To Adapt It For Your Niche:
Pick A “Big Goal”: A major objective in your niche that successful people have achieved.
Pick A “Small Goal”: Choose a specific challenge or obstacle commonly faced by beginners in your niche — it should relate to the big goal you’ve already picked.
Give Actionable Advice: Insights and strategies on how to achieve the big goal while overcoming the challenge/obstacle.
💨 Speed Things Up With ChatGPT:
Not sure where to start?
Copy and paste the following into ChatGPT after filling in your niche.
Hi ChatGPT,
I'm a content creator in the [insert niche] niche and I want to create a piece of content using the following headline template:
"How Successful [People In Your Niche] Achieve [Big Goal] (+ Why You Can’t Even [Achieve Small Goal])".
It's modeled on the following headline:
“How Successful People Achieve Multiple Goals (+ Why You Can't Even Manage One)”
Please provide 10 tailored headline ideas that follow the headline template and resonate with my niche audience.
🎨 Examples Using The Template:
For Creators:
Fitness: “How Pro Athletes Achieve Olympic-Level Endurance (+ Why You Can’t Even Run 5K)”
Photography: “How Landscapers Build Award-Winning Rose Gardens (+ Why You Can’t Even Keep One Alive)”
For Businesses Doing Content Marketing (B2C):
Parenting: “How Some New Parents Get Great Sleep (+ Why You Can’t Even Get 4 Hours)”
Music Education: “How Pro Pianists Practice For 6 Hours A Day (+ Why You Can’t Even Do 45 Minutes)”
For Businesses Doing Content Marketing (B2B):
Digital Marketing: “How Successful Instagrammers Go Viral (+ Why You Can’t Even Get To 10K Followers)”
HR Consultancy: “How Businesses Achieve 90% Employment Retention (+ Why You Can’t Even Get 25%)”
🏅 HOOK OF THE DAY
Gary Halbert’s “Coat Of Arms” Letter
Master copywriter Gary Halbert mailed this 1-page beauty to more than 600,000,000 people over 30 years.
A personalized letter selling family crests and associated historical information.
At its peak, this simple letter was bringing in an eye-popping 20,000 orders per day.
Here’s the hook:
“Dear Mr. Macdonald,
Did you know that your family name was recorded with a coat of arms in ancient heraldic archives more than seven centuries ago?”
How could anyone with the name Macdonald not read on for more information?
🧠 Hook Psychology
Exclusivity: By appealing to a sense of heritage, the letter triggers feelings of pride and importance.
Ownership: The mention of a “family coat of arms” immediately creates a sense of ownership — we value things more when we own them (see the “Endowment Effect”).
💡 Hook Takeaway: Personalization and exclusivity can make for an irresistible hook.
Did you find today's newsletter content valuable? |