- The Pen Pivot
- Posts
- The Dead-Simple Headline-Writing Hack Pro Creators Are Keeping Secret
The Dead-Simple Headline-Writing Hack Pro Creators Are Keeping Secret
It’s ridiculous but it works

Welcome to The Pen Pivot!
Our free newsletter teaches 5K+ creators the psychology-backed secrets behind getting people to click, read, and view their content 🧠.
In today’s email:
A Quick And Dirty Headline Trick 🎇 - Generate more clicks and views with this ridiculously simple headline formula.
Tool Of The Day 🛠️ - A beautifully simple community-building tool for content creators.

30 SECONDS TO THE PERFECT HEADLINE: EASY 3-STEP GUIDE
Sad truth:
Whether it’s written, video, or audio, the success of a piece of content often depends on the handful of words at the very top.
No matter how much blood, sweat, and tears you may have poured into it, without a good headline you might as well not have written it.
I’d like to think of myself as a headline collector.
When I see the top content creators consistently writing headlines in a very specific way, I start to take notice.
There’s one pattern I’ve seen everywhere.
On Medium, YouTube, the “trending” section of major publications, and more.
Sure, I don’t have access to their specific click-through rates.
But when something is used by the best, everywhere, it’s a pretty good indication that it works.
The headline format appears to play on a simple psychological effect:
Cognitive fluency:
People prefer information that’s easy to process. When you break down a complex topic into simple steps, you make it more cognitively fluent.
The suggestion of cognitively fluent information is what makes people curious.
Here’s how you too can use this effect to write headlines that people can’t help but click on.
“Simplify The Complex”: Steal This 3-Step Headline-Writing Hack
Find a topic widely seen as overwhelming that you understand well
Promise an actionable solution
Promise they’ll achieve it within a specific time duration
Here are a couple of examples:
1. Find A Topic
As Dickie Bush would say, if you can’t find a complex topic you understand well, you probably aren’t getting specific enough.
There’s a very good chance you’re an “expert” in something.
Don’t think as broad as astrophysics or geology.
Think small.
What are the little nuggets of expertise you have that most other people haven’t figured out yet?
Alternatively, seek out expertise from others. Interview them and document their process.
Let’s use an example from the baking niche:
Baking the perfect sourdough bread.
A starting point for your headline would be this:
“How To Bake The Perfect Sourdough Bread”.
Bland and forgettable, but it’s a start.
Let’s see where it takes us.
2. Offer A Clear, Actionable Solution
Audiences don’t want fluff.
They’re seeking value, answers, or a new skill.
The headline should promise a solution that isn’t just easy to understand, but also actionable.
Use active verbs and clearly state the outcome they should expect.
Let’s revamp our headline:
“Bake Perfect Sourdough Bread Using These 4 Steps”
Specificity is strength.
By identifying the number of steps, you set a clear expectation for the reader/viewer.
A concise, actionable list makes a topic much more cognitively fluent and appealing.
3. Create Urgency With A Timeline
Adding a specific timeframe contributes two things:
It adds a sense of urgency.
It adds precision, making the goal appear even more achievable.
This lets the audience know that if they click this headline, they won’t just find solutions to their problems.
They’ll also achieve them within a reasonable, finite period.
Now, let’s finish up with our headline.
“6 Hours To Perfect Sourdough Bread: A Simple 4-Step Guide”.
Much better.
But surely there’s more we can do?
“Simplify The Complex”: Steal This 3-Step Headline-Writing Hack
Increase the curiosity gap by adding a sense of mystery or exclusivity:
“6 Hours To Perfect Sourdough Bread: An Unusual 4-Step Guide”.
Social proof/authority bias:
“6 Hours To Sourdough Bread: The 4-Step Guide Pro Bakers Use”.
Maybe combine them?
“6 Hrs To Sourdough Bread: A Pro Baker’s Unusual 4-Step Guide”.
Of course, this would only work if it actually was a pro baker’s technique and there was something unique about it.
I’m just spitballing here.
If you wanted to, you could amp up the simplicity instead:
“6 Hours To No-Hassle Sourdough Bread: A 4-Step Guide”
And so on.
Your Next Steps:
Apply the 3-step framework to future informational content
Experiment: A/B test to see if it makes a difference
As always, a good headline will only get you the click.
Actually delivering valuable content that meets audience expectations is just as essential.
-TOOL OF THE DAY-
Circle
Circle is an all-in-one community platform that empowers content creators to:
Build engaging courses
Connect with members
Host live streams
Facilitate discussions
Offer memberships
All under their own brand.
With Circle, creators can combine their content with interactive community features.
The result?
A seamless and vibrant experience for their audience.
(Not sponsored)
Did you find today's newsletter content valuable? |
And that’s all for today!
Dilshan And Misya, The Pen Pivot